Wexford suicide; what is being done?

On Thursday (8thDec), eight inquests were performed in the Wexford Coroner’s Court. Six of these Inquests involved suicide.

I would like to know what is being done about this, is it just being accepted? Did any of our (extremely well paid) ‘esteemed’ experts take the opportunity to figure out if there was a common denominator here? Were any or all of these victims on medication with known suicidal side-effects, usually antidepressants? Did any of our ‘top’ experts on suicidology use this opportunity to get to the underlying cause? I realise that suicide is a very sensitive subject and not all families want (or are able) to talk about the suicide of family members, but some, like my family will want to know the reasons behind it.

I have previously spoken to a person from the central statistics office who told me that there are no statistics held for suicide victims and the medication they were on at the time of their death. This is done in other countries, so why not here? A Swedish writer, Janne Larrson, has written a paper on the subject. Here.

Wexford has had a big problem with suicide for a number of years; in 2005 the Irish Independent reported that Wexford had the second highest rate of suicide in the country.

I personally spoke to a pathologist, whose name I won’t mention, who said, that in the last 5 autopsies that he has performed on suicide victims, 4 had been recently introduced to an ssri antidepressant. His opinion is that there is a big problem in this country with these drugs. He also said that after one particular Inquest, he was approached by one of Irelands ‘leading’ psychiatrists who said that if he continued to say what he was saying, he would be doing Irish Psychiatry out of their jobs.

For the benefit of people in countries not originally colonized by England, who have no idea what an inquest is; A Coroner conducts an inquest (in public) into any violent, suspicious or unexplained death. The purpose of an Inquest is to determine ‘who, how, when and where’ a person has died. In Ireland, Inquests are regulated by The Coroners Act 1962.

A letter published coincidently on Thurs 8th, in the Irish Times Letter section prompted, I think, by Dr Moosajee Bhamjee’s proposal to add lithium to Irish drinking water in a bid to lower the suicide rate (more medication, did he ever hear of informed consent), gives his opinion on psychiatry and their practice of medicating for human distress!

A chara, – If any branch of medicine thinks it can medicate its way out of a “problem”, it is psychiatry. Irrespective of attacks on human and constitutional rights (letters, passim) the idea of putting lithium into drinking water is flippant and fanciful.

While depressive symptoms arising out of adverse social conditions might be “managed” this way, the causes – unemployment, poverty, deprivation, negative equity – remain untouched. However, if psychiatrists could prescribe money in the way the Government “prescribed” it for the banks and bondholders . . . – Is mise,

MICHAEL NASH,

Lecturer in Psychiatric Nursing,

School of Nursing and

Midwifery,

Trinity College Dublin,

D’Olier Street, Dublin 2.

2 thoughts on “Wexford suicide; what is being done?

  1. Hi Leonie

    Great piece of research from Sweden. Like you I have looked at the CSO statistics along with reports from the NOSP and asked myself why that data regarding pharmacological intervention hasn’t been included. I think your conversation with the pathologist explains that one!

    The figures about Wexford are also very interesting particularly in light of the fact that the of the seven members of the 2007 Subcomittee on Adverse Reactions the only remaining Oireachtas member is a TD from Wexford who also happens to be an MD. It would be very interesting to find out what his take on this is.

    As for the Lithium in the water, I think Dr Bhamjee’s proposal (as barmy as it is) has actually done those of us in the anti bio-pharma group a big favour as it has opened up debate about the use of medications in general. It seems more and more people are starting to realise the level of deception that the pharmaceutical companies have been engaged in regarding promotion of their products.

    Like

  2. Well, thats a damn lie, of course there are statistical reports of medicinal and suicidal categories.
    It makes me so angry when lies like this are told to us.
    This is so typical of the industry, they are liars all of them.
    Have you looked into the DWP/ATOS bullying of all disabled and mentally affected claimants.? Funny how the statistical reports are calculated on depressives being ‘fakes’ and ‘lazy’ but no reports of suicidal potentials being forced into or, back to, work placements that are likely to push people as far as any limit possible.

    Funny how this unelected government is going out of its way to destroy benefits/healthcare and do its utmost to keep the brain drug situation without ‘statistical reporting’.
    Sinister isnt it

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s